A Margherita pizza has tomato, mozzarella, fresh basil and a little olive oil on a yeast-raised dough base. With this short ingredient list, you can taste the tangy tomato, mild cheese and fragrant basil without extra toppings or heavy seasoning.
You'll find variations in crust thickness, the amount of cheese and baking style, but you should still recognise the tomato, mozzarella and basil combination. It isn't simply any pizza with cheese.
What goes into a Margherita pizza?
You need a dough base and a few carefully chosen toppings. With so few ingredients, you'll easily notice overly salty cheese, watery sauce or a dry base.
- Pizza dough: Flour, water, yeast and salt form the basic dough. Some home recipes include a little oil, but you don't need sugar or oil to make a Margherita.
- Tomato: Crushed peeled tomatoes or a simple tomato sauce add acidity, moisture and a little sweetness.
- Mozzarella: This mild cheese adds a creamy flavour and a soft, melted texture without overwhelming the tomato.
- Fresh basil: Whole or torn leaves add a distinctive aroma that you won't get from dried mixed herbs.
- Olive oil and salt: A light drizzle of oil adds flavour, while a little salt balances the tomato and dough.
You'll find garlic, chilli flakes, oregano and grated hard cheese in some recipes, but you don't need them for the basic version. If you're trying it for the first time, start with the simpler combination so you can judge its flavour.
How do you choose toppings for a Margherita?
Which tomatoes should you use?
Good-quality peeled, tinned tomatoes work well. Crush them by hand or blend them briefly. You can also use passata if it isn't too thin. Taste the tomato before adding salt, and avoid sauces with overpowering amounts of sugar, garlic or dried herbs.
You don't always need to cook the sauce first. A thin layer of crushed tomato can cook directly on the pizza. If your tomatoes release a lot of liquid, drain some off or gently reduce the sauce before using it. Aim for a topping you can spread easily without soaking the dough.
Which mozzarella should you use?
Fresh mozzarella made from cow's milk gives you a mild, milky flavour. You can also use buffalo-milk mozzarella, though its flavour and moisture content can differ. Tear or slice fresh mozzarella, then let it drain before you top the pizza.
Drain fresh mozzarella rather than tipping liquid from the packet onto the base. You want soft pools of cheese, not a puddle in the centre. Low-moisture mozzarella is a practical alternative for a home oven, although it usually gives you a more even, stretchy layer of cheese and a less milky flavour.
What makes a good Margherita pizza?
In a well-made Margherita, you should taste a balance of bread, tomato and cheese in each bite. Look for fresh, pleasantly tangy tomato, mild mozzarella and a noticeable basil aroma that doesn't overpower the other ingredients.
With a traditional high-heat bake, you'll usually get a thin, tender centre with a raised, airy rim and scattered browned spots. Other ovens and dough recipes can give you a firmer or crisper base, so you can't judge whether a pizza is a Margherita by crispness alone.
Look for a cooked, not soggy centre. A tender middle can fold when you lift a slice, but you shouldn't find a gummy layer of raw dough. A little moisture around fresh mozzarella is normal. If you see excessive liquid, the toppings may be too wet or the pizza may need more time in the oven.
How is Margherita different from a cheese pizza?
A plain cheese pizza is a broader category. You'll usually get tomato sauce and cheese, but the cheese may cover the entire surface, include several varieties or have stronger seasoning. You won't necessarily get fresh basil.
With a Margherita, you can expect tomato, mozzarella and basil, often with patches of red sauce visible between the melted cheese. Don't rely only on appearance, though, because some cooks use grated mozzarella rather than separate pieces.
You can generally expect a meat-free pizza, but check the cheese's rennet if you follow a strict vegetarian diet. Some cheeses contain animal-derived rennet, which helps milk set into curds. Check the vegetarian declaration on packaged cheese or ask the restaurant about the cheese it uses.
How do you make Margherita pizza at home?
Your main challenge is to bake the dough thoroughly without drying out the toppings. Use a hot oven, preheat your baking surface properly and go easy on the toppings to get a better result.
- Preheat your oven and baking surface thoroughly. Follow the temperature limits for your oven, pizza stone, steel or tray.
- Stretch the dough evenly, keeping the centre thin and leaving a slightly thicker rim if you want an airy edge.
- Spread a thin layer of tomato over the centre, leaving the rim uncovered. Add drained mozzarella with space between the pieces.
- Bake until the underside is cooked, the rim has browned and the cheese has melted. Look for these signs rather than relying on a fixed cooking time.
- Add basil and a light drizzle of olive oil. If your home oven needs a longer bake, add the basil near the end or just after baking to help prevent scorching.
You can add mushrooms, olives, paneer or other toppings, but you'll move away from the classic combination. If you want to keep its characteristic balance, make the basic version first and serve chilli flakes or extra seasoning separately.