How Is Pan Pizza Different from Hand-Tossed Pizza?

The main difference between pan pizza and hand-tossed pizza is how you shape and bake the dough. For pan pizza, you let the dough rise and bake in an oiled pan. For hand-tossed pizza, you stretch it by hand and usually bake it on a hot surface or screen. Pan pizza generally has a thicker, airy centre and a crisp, oil-browned base. Hand-tossed pizza usually has a thinner centre, a chewy rim and a less oily finish. These are typical differences, not fixed rules, so check the crust description before you order.

How do you make pan pizza and hand-tossed pizza?

For pan pizza, you place a portion of dough in a greased pan and gently press or stretch it towards the edges. You usually let it rest and rise in the pan before adding toppings. The pan supports the dough as it expands, helping you create a thick base with a fairly even height.

For hand-tossed pizza, you stretch the dough into a round using your fingers, knuckles or hands. Despite the name, tossing is optional: you can stretch the base entirely on the worktop and over your hands. Leave the outer edge less compressed to help it puff up during baking.

The labels describe different things. “Pan” refers mainly to the baking vessel, while “hand-tossed” refers to how you shape the dough. You can put hand-stretched dough in a pan, but on menus, these names usually distinguish a thicker pan-baked crust from a thinner, hand-stretched one.

How do the crusts differ?

You'll see the clearest difference when you look at a cut slice. Pan pizza typically has more bread beneath the toppings, with an open, springy interior. Hand-tossed pizza usually has a thinner centre and a more pronounced raised rim, although the exact thickness depends on how much dough you use and how wide you stretch it.

  • Pan pizza base: Usually crisp and well browned underneath, with a richer texture from the oil in the pan.
  • Pan pizza interior: Generally soft and airy, though it can turn dense if you don't let the dough rise sufficiently.
  • Hand-tossed base: Usually thinner, with a texture that ranges from crisp to flexible depending on how you bake it.
  • Hand-tossed rim: Often chewy and puffy, with larger air pockets where you leave the dough uncompressed.

Neither style guarantees a crisp slice. Too much sauce, wet toppings or too little time in the oven can soften either base. You can get a crisper underside on a thick pan crust than on a thin hand-tossed crust if you let the pan base brown properly.

How do toppings affect each pizza crust?

A thicker pan base generally supports more toppings without folding as easily. With more bread in each bite, though, you may find a lightly topped slice too bready. You might prefer a little more sauce or stronger-flavoured toppings, but too much moisture can leave the layer beneath them gummy.

With a thinner hand-tossed centre, you'll taste more of the sauce, cheese and toppings in each bite. Keep the toppings reasonably light if you want the slice to hold its shape. A heavily topped centre may sag even when you've baked the outer rim thoroughly.

For either style, limit moisture from toppings. Drain ingredients packed in liquid, pat fresh mozzarella dry and avoid piling wet vegetables in one spot. Cook raw meat toppings before adding them unless you're following a tested recipe designed to cook them safely on the pizza.

If you spread cheese right to the sides of a pan, it can form a browned, crisp edge. You'll find this on some pan pizzas, but you don't need it for every version.

Is hand-tossed pizza lighter than pan pizza?

You may find hand-tossed pizza less filling because its centre contains less bread, but the name alone doesn't tell you its calorie content. Dough weight, pan oil, cheese quantity, toppings and portion size all affect the total. A heavily topped hand-tossed pizza can contain more calories than a modestly topped pan pizza.

For a useful comparison, check the serving size before comparing calories, saturated fat or sodium. The US Food and Drug Administration explains that nutrition information on a label usually refers to one serving, rather than the whole pack. You can't compare pizzas reliably by the slice if they have different diameters or numbers of slices.

If you can find nutrition information, compare similar amounts of pizza. If you can't, choose the crust texture you enjoy, then consider how much cheese, processed meat and extra oil you want rather than assuming either crust is healthier.

Which pizza should you choose?

Choose the texture you want rather than assuming one style is better than the other. You can get excellent results with both if you let the dough ferment properly and bake the base through.

  • Choose pan pizza if you enjoy a substantial, soft centre with a crisp, richly browned underside.
  • Choose hand-tossed pizza if you prefer a thinner centre and a chewy, raised edge.
  • Choose a well-baked pan crust if you want a sturdy base for generous toppings.
  • Choose a lightly topped hand-tossed base if you want less bread beneath the sauce and cheese.

When you order, ask how thick the crust is and what texture you can expect from the base. Terms such as “classic”, “regular” and “original” don't reliably describe either style.

How can you make either style at home?

For pan pizza, use a suitable metal baking pan and grease its base evenly. Give the dough time to relax if it springs back as you stretch it, then let it rise as your recipe directs. Check the underside before you take the pizza out of the pan: melted cheese doesn't mean you've baked the thick base through.

For hand-tossed pizza, stretch from the centre outwards without flattening the rim. Avoid forcing cold, tight dough into shape, as you can tear it. Use only enough dusting flour to prevent sticking, and preheat your baking stone, steel or tray thoroughly according to its instructions.

For both styles, avoid overloading the centre. Follow a recipe suited to your oven and baking surface rather than copying cooking times meant for different equipment. Move your finished pan pizza onto a rack briefly so trapped steam doesn't soften the underside before you slice it.

Sources